There are many different gutter guards and gutter guards to choose from. Our in-depth review looks at two of the leading gutter guard companies, LeafFilter vs. Gutterglove. Our goal in this LeafFilter vs. Gutterglove comparison? To help you choose the best gutter guards for your home.
In this review comparing LeafFilter and Gutterglove, we looked at the services offered, prices, customer reviews, and much more.
Let’s get started…
Table of Contents
- LeafFilter and Gutterglove At A Glance
- Product Overview
- Availability and Pricing
- LeafFilter Vs. Gutterglove Installation
- Quality Guarantees
- Customer Support
- User Reviews
- Pros and Cons of Each
- LeafFilter FAQs
- Gutterglove FAQs
LeafFilter and Gutterglove at A Glance
LeafFilter Gutter Protection System began in 2005 in the basement of company founder Matt Kaulig. He sought a better way to protect gutters from clogging and came up with the LeafFilter system. Over the years, the small company grew into what is widely considered one of the top home improvement companies in the nation.
Headquartered in Hudson, Ohio, LeafFilter Gutter Protection offers a gutter guard system that is designed to draw in water while efficiently keeping out debris.
Gutterglove traces its roots to 1996, when Robert Lenney began the work that would lead to the invention of the Gutterglove system. Lenney had worked for a gutter cleaning company and believed that most of the existing gutter guards weren’t performing as expected.
Lenney founded Gutterglove Inc. in Roseville, California.
Today, Gutterglove produces stainless steel micro-mesh gutter guards that can be installed professionally or by a DIYer.
LeafFilter vs. Gutterglove: Product Overview
Both companies specialize in making products that are touted as some of the best gutter guards on the market today. Both micro-mesh gutter guards have unique properties that allow them to keep debris out of your downspouts efficiently. So, let’s go over the details of both systems to see how they work.
LeafFilter Gutter Protection utilizes a micro-mesh screen made from surgical-grade stainless steel. The mesh is only 275 microns fine, which is tiny enough to keep even shingle grit out of your gutter. Below the mesh sits a durable uPVC filter, installed at an angle to ensure the shedding of small debris caught in the micro-mesh layer.
When water comes into contact with the micro-mesh layer at the top of the LeafFilter gutter guard, surface tension draws it down through the filter. The entire system is sealed, allowing no holes or gaps to further ensure that grit, seed pods, pine needles, and other small particles stay out of your gutter.
Gutterglove gutter guards are made from a lightweight 316-micron stainless steel micro-mesh that bends to fit your unique roof configuration. Gutterglove gutter guards attach to any existing gutter, new gutter, fascia boards, or drip edge with self-tapping screws or 3M high-bond tape that comes pre-applied to each 4-foot section of your gutter guards, making DIY installation a breeze.
Additionally, Gutterglove offers professionally installed gutter guards through its DoneRight Partner Program. DoneRight is an incentivized award program for its network of contractors involved in the selling and installation of Gutterglove products. The gutter guards installed through the professional program fall under three different brands:
- Gutterglove Pro combines a high-quality stainless steel micro-mesh with a sturdy, anodized aluminum frame that holds up under harsh conditions, such as high winds and falling tree branches. Its V-Bend design allows it to lift fine debris while improving water flow through the guard.
- LeafBlaster Pro incorporates patented Z-Bend technology into a fine micro-mesh that lifts debris, allowing it to blow off naturally rather than sitting on top of the mesh. The LeafBlaster is also designed with an angled front trough that directs water into your gutters and prevents it from splashing over the edge.
- MicroMesh Pro gutter guards are made with a surgical-grade stainless steel mesh connected to a hardened aluminum extruded drip edge that fastens easily to the front lip of any gutter. Using a series of corrugated V-bends to create a sturdy structure, the MicroMesh Pro doesn’t require a metal support frame.
LeafFilter vs. Gutterglove: Availability and Pricing
The availability and price of their products can be a major factor when comparing companies like LeafFilter and Gutterglove.
LeafFilter’s gutter guards are available only for professional installation through its website. Just key in your ZIP code, email address, the number of levels in your home, and the square footage of your home to receive a free estimate.
On average, LeafFilter’s gutter guards cost between $15 and $45 per linear foot. The cost varies based on the linear footage required, how many stories your home has, and whether gutter repair and cleaning services are included in your installation costs. Materials and installation are included in the pricing.
You can order professional installation from Gutterglove’s DoneRight contractor program. The cost of professional installation varies depending on the area, linear footage, and the contractor.
For home improvement enthusiasts, Gutterglove kits are also sold for DIY installation at the following retailers:
- The Home Depot
- Sam’s Club
Gutterglove’s DIY gutter guard kits cost between $15 and $215 based on the retailer and the size and slope of your roof.
LeafFilter vs. Gutterglove Installation
LeafFilter and Gutterglove both use qualified contractors for professional installations, but only Gutterglove offers a DIY approach for those who wish for a more hands-on method.
You can contact LeafFilter to schedule a free estimate either by filling out an online form on the website or by phone at 1-800-290-6106. A contractor will come to your home to assess your gutters and roof and offer recommendations. Once this process is completed, you will receive a quote that is good for up to one year.
For Gutterglove’s professional services, you can request a free estimate by providing your name, phone number, email address, and ZIP code on the website. Once you do this, you will be asked which Gutterglove product you would like to have installed to determine your estimate.
For the DIY approach, installing the Gutterglove system is simple:
- Inspect your gutters for any damage or leaks and thoroughly clean debris out of them.
- Measure the angle of your roof slope, which will help determine whether you slide the gutter guard under the roof shingles or bend the back of the mesh up or down and fasten it to the back of the gutter or fascia.
- Follow the installation process guide when cutting and joining sections of the Gutterglove system, dealing with end caps, and removing any gaps that may appear during the process.
LeafFilter vs. Gutterglove: Quality Guarantees
Both LeafFilter and Gutterglove offer micro-mesh gutter guards with similar qualities. But how does each company ensure customer satisfaction with their products? Let’s take a look at the stamp of approval that LeafFilter and Gutterglove have placed on their gutter guards.
LeafFilter gutter guards come with a limited lifetime warranty that lasts as long as you own your home. Should you sell your home, this warranty is fully transferable. If a LeafFilter gutter guard ever allows your downspouts to clog and overflow, causing water damage to your home, LeafFilter North LLC will provide a replacement or refund you 100% of the material purchase price for all LeafFilter products installed on your home.
If a Gutterglove product develops a defect in any of its parts, the company will, at its option only, repair or replace the defective part with a new or reconditioned equivalent. This warranty is valid for 40 years for parts only and does not extend to the cost of labor. In coastal areas, defined as any area within five miles of the coast, the lifetime of this warranty is reduced to 10 years.
Additionally, at its discretion, Gutterglove’s DoneRight contractors may offer their own warranty on top of the existing parts warranty.
A company is only as good as its customer support. If you encounter any issues or questions regarding LeafFilter or Gutterglove’s products, it’s important to know who to call to help resolve them.
If you have questions about LeafFilter’s products, you can call 1-800-290-6106, the same number you would use to request your free quote. You can call LeafFilter’s customer service and support department at 1-800-749-4566.
GutterGlove offers a wider variety of contact methods for its customer service department. You can contact the support department for each of its products at 1-800-831-5108. You can also send an email to email@example.com.
Comparing the customer ratings and reviews of two companies is often the deciding factor for many homeowners looking into a service. Gutterglove and LeafFilter both have reviews on reputable sites like TrustPilot and Sitejabber. Both companies have an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau, though LeafFilter is accredited with the BBB, whereas Gutterglove is not.
Here is a side-by-side comparison of each company’s average ratings on Sitejabber and TrustPilot.
|Gutterglove||Rating: 4.7 across 143 reviews||Rating: 4.9 across 396 reviews|
|LeafFilter||Rating: 4.4 across 99,412 reviews||Rating: 2.1 across 28 reviews|
To further highlight customer experiences, we’ve included a selection of positive and negative customer reviews of both companies.
Best product on the market: “The product itself is top rated, and installation is very fast. Estimators and technicians explain every step, and the best part of all is the transferrable warranty that adds to the value of our home. We had the whole house done April 2, 2019, and just had the outside 2-car garage done a few weeks ago, after all new shingles/roofing.” – George F., TrustPilot
Totally impressed: “I researched this product online and was contacted by them. I agreed for an appointment and found the representative very polite and knowledgeable. I was impressed with the demonstration and guarantee. The installation went great and the technician really knew his job. He was surprised that we had chipmunks climbing up the inside of our gutter drains. He installed screens at no extra charge. We just had a real heavy rain storm and I observed that these units work amazing. We are extremely pleased with our experience with this company.” – Jeannette W., Sitejabber
Fast and efficient: “Fast installation, miminal impact. On the negative side, the sales experience was like buying a car. Negotiating with a salesman over a flexible price is not a pleasant experience. One good thing about buying a car is you don’t need to do it again for a while. The leaf filter guarantee seems good on the surface, but I suspect that negotiation would be required should something turn up down the road. – William H., TrustPilot
Do not work: “I spent over $5,000 installing LeafFilter on my house and garage. They continue to clog, not the gutter, but the leaf filter itself fills with pine needles and of course, they do not work. I have called, and they came out to clean them once, now they say I have to pay for the service. I have asked for a refund since the way it was sold to me was I would never have a clog again, and never have to clean them again, which is not true.” – David Z., Sitejabber
Great product: “I just installed 188 linear feet of this product, and it was very easy. I used the self-tapping screws, and they really secure the guards to the gutter. The stainless steel guard looks like it will last for many years to come. Hopefully, I only need to brush them off once a year to keep them free from leaves and other stuff that falls from all the trees that surround my house.” – Greg F., TrustPilot
Professional and personal use: “I’ve used Gutterglove on the new homes I’ve built for years and have never had a complaint, So I’ve installed it on my personal home. So far so good.” – Jim O., Sitejabber
Difficult installation: “This is a good product but not so easily installed. I had to bend every piece in order to install it on my gutters. When I did, some of the screen detached from the aluminum rails. It would be much better if gutterglove was made to fit the various sized gutters without having to bench each piece and if the rails were pre-drilled.” – Curt G., TrustPilot
Still overflowed: “My first heavy rain, leaves were on the gutter, but the gutter still overflowed and water came into the house through a window.” – Susan S., Sitejabber
Pros and Cons of LeafFilter and Gutterglove
Gutterglove and LeafFilter are both award-winning companies with a product that guarantees protection against the finest debris getting into your gutters. Every home and homeowner has different needs when it comes to gutter guards, so while we can’t tell you which one is the best gutter guard, we can summarize our findings so you can make an informed decision.
These pros and cons are comparative and based on product information, gutter guard reviews from customers, and the BBB.
Gutterglove Pros and Cons
|✓ Fits any roof configuration|
✓ Thinner micro-mesh design for better filtering of debris
✓ Professional or DIY options for installation
✓ Increased avenues for contacting customer service
|✗ Warranty covers only repair and replacement of parts|
✗ Homeowners in coastal areas receive a 10-year warranty rather than a 40-year warranty
✗ More expensive
✗ DIY installation can be complicated without extensive knowledge of gutters
✗ No BBB accreditation
LeafFilter Pros and Cons
|✓ Lifetime warranty that covers replacements and 100% refunds|
✓ Warranty is fully transferable
✓ Faster installation
✓ Less expensive option
✓ Accredited with the BBB
|✗ Micro-mesh can get clogged by pine needles|
✗ Professional installation only
✗ Customer service available only by phone
LeafFilter vs. Gutterglove: Our Verdict
- Lifetime transferable warranty
- Filters even the smallest debris particles
- Installation is done only by professionals
FAQ About LeafFilter
LeafFilter works quite well in snowy climates. The snow sits on top of the micro-mesh filter instead of falling through to your gutters. Once it melts, the runoff gets filtered through the mesh just like any other water.
Yes, the micro-mesh material installed with LeafFilter is designed to withstand heavy downpours without sustaining damage.
FAQ About Gutterglove
Will Gutterglove gutter guards rust or warp?
No, the Gutterglove system is made with lightweight stainless steel. Despite the lower weight, these gutter guards are designed to resist corrosion, rust, and warping from the elements.
Is Gutterglove difficult to install on your own?
No, for those who wish to go down the DIY path, Gutterglove is intended to be one of the simpler systems. However, it still requires knowledge of your roof and gutters, accurate measurements, and the correct materials to install them properly.